More on the SFE and ICGE Opportunity
The anomaly I have been discussing between the share prices of ^SFE^ and ^ICGE^ has now largely disappeared, as anomalies do when they are made public. Although the 27-point difference no longer exists, SFE is still selling for a little less than ICGE (SFE today is trading around 161 and ICGE is trading higher, around 165). However, the exact amount of SFE’s proper premium over ICGE is not clear, as it depends upon the valuation of SFE’s other assets, an uncertain science in today’s environment.
An option on SFE is an option to purchase one round lot of SFE stock, which contains as part of its ownership one round lot of ICGE stock. Thus a call option on SFE is also a call on ICGE. When you purchase a share of SFE, in the process you also purchase a share of ICGE. So let’s think of a call on SFE as an option to purchase a round lot of ICGE stock plus a round lot’s share of the other assets of SFE.
As the gross anomaly that previously existed between these two stocks no longer exists, to make the arithmetic simple and illustrate the concepts I will assume that SFE is selling for 100 and ICGE is selling for 120. This analysis therefore will not apply to the current situation but will serve to guide you, should you ever encounter another such situation.
Let’s also assume that the options on these two stocks are priced roughly according to their Black Scholes values (if they are not, these commentaries and the advanced trading articles on the site have shown you other hedging techniques to exploit those inefficiencies). A call on SFE is a call to purchase a round lot of SFE, which includes a round lot of ICGE plus a round lot’s share of the other assets of SFE. So certainly a 100 call on SFE, which gives you the right to purchase SFE at any time between now and expiration of the call for $100, has an intrinsic value today of at least $20.
Using a simplified annualized volatility of 100% for both stocks, the Feb 100 call on SFE has a Black Scholes value of $14.22, and the Feb 120 put on ICGE has a Black Scholes value of $26.85. Let’s assume these are also the market prices.
Ordinarily, if a call option is selling for less than intrinsic value, you need merely exercise the option, thereby purchasing the stock for a price lower than the current market price, and then sell the stock in the open market for a profit. This operation is so simple to understand that options rarely sell for less than intrinsic value and then only for a minor amount that only floor operations can exploit. In this case, if you exercise the 100 call on SFE, you will own a round lot of SFE at a price in excess of the price you would pay in the marketplace. Even the first step in this process is not advisable.
There are a number of interesting questions here. For one, how can you exploit the fact that the SFE 100 call is selling below its intrinsic value? For another, one of the positions I mentioned in the previous commentary was (+1 SFE call, +1 SFE put). What is the expected profit from this position?
It is worth thinking about these problems in detail and I encourage you to do so. More next time.