• Free Book
  • Store
    • Books
    • Free First Chapters
    • Free Newsletters
  • Recent Articles

TradingMarkets.com

Quantified Stock Market Trading Strategies & Systems

  • Home
  • New Trading Research
  • Education
    • Articles
      • Connors Research
      • ETFs
      • Options
      • Stocks
      • Volatility
    • Trading Lessons
    • Connors Research
    • Glossary
    • Interview Archive
    • Videos
  • Python
  • Quantamentals
    • Quantamentals: The Next Great Forefront of Trading and Investing
    • Quantamentals Resources
  • Courses
  • Store
    • New Book! The Alpha Formula
    • “Buy The Fear, Sell The Greed” – Best Seller!
    • Swing Trading College 2019
    • Trading Books and Guidebooks
    • Street Smarts
    • Online Trading Courses
    • Private Mentoring with Larry Connors
    • Customized Trading Research
    • Amibroker Strategy Add On Modules
You are here: Home / Recent / Are Analysts’ Estimates Important to Stock Prices? – Part 1

Are Analysts’ Estimates Important to Stock Prices? – Part 1

September 5, 2008 by John Jagerson

I get emails from investors all the time asking why some stocks with declining earnings will gain in value following their earnings announcement despite the fact that the news sounds “bad”.

Usually the response I give is the same one reported in the news that despite the decline it was not as bad as “estimates” and therefore the stock has been discounted too much and will rise in value.

That response sounds reasonable but it leads to the question of where do these estimates come from? They come from stock analysts who issue forward looking estimates or forecasts about what a stock is likely to do in the future both in terms of stock price and the underlying financial fundamentals.

Stock analysts typically work for investment banks or brokerages and although they are supposed to be independent of the investment banking services and sales organizations they rarely are. It is very common for an investment bank that is underwriting and/or investing in a public company to also be issuing “unbiased” analyst reports on the same firm. This common problem throws some doubt on the neutrality of these reports.

Most large stocks have more that one analyst/bank issuing reports and estimates on the company. Although analysts are notoriously bullish on everything they cover, the coverage can still be a source of interesting information. The reports are easy to access through information service providers like Reuters, Thompson or Bloomberg who will compile several analyst reports into summary information that is frequently republished on major financial portals like Yahoo! Finance or Google Finance. Those average ratings and estimates are what the media will most often point to as “market expectations.” For example, LOW estimates for earnings were $0.51 a share before the release today but actual earnings only dropped to $0.64 per share. That difference was a positive earnings surprise and is considered bullish. The estimates number will vary depending on which analysts were surveyed and who is reporting the composite or average rating but most average reports will show that LOW did exceed estimates.

alt=”LOW Chart” pbsrc=”http://images.tradingmarkets.com/2008/HowTo/0827Jagerson2.png” pbCaption=”” onclick=”Pop(this,50,’PopBoxImageLarge’);” width=”550″ height=”350″ class=”PopBoxImageSmall” title=”Click to magnify/shrink” />

Do analyst estimates matter to the stock long term or is it merely a convenient explanation for short term volatility? I would argue that analysts estimates have little if any affect on a stock’s performance or even the market at large in the long term. For example, LOW has positively surprised analysts in its last 4 quarterly reports and you can see (in the chart below) that after an initial bump the stock retraced to follow the general market trend to the downside. This situation is typical of most large stocks and it is a great example of why diversification is so important. Traders can easily be shaken by missed or exceeded earnings reports into getting out too early despite the fact that these reports have little predictive value. Holding a broader, diversified-portfolio of stocks helps smooth these price shocks out.

Analysts do have some redeeming value as well. In part-two of this article I will show you how to access analyst reports and more importantly how to listen to analysts quiz a company’s management team during each quarter’s earnings calls. These calls are more spontaneous than the analyst reports and good information about a company’s prospects, strategy and competitive environment is frequently heard.

In part 2, John Jagerson shows you how a company’s management team is quizzed by analysts during quarterly earnings calls. To read Part 2 of our series on analysts’ estimates, Click Here.

John Jagerson is the author of many investing books and is a co-founder of LearningMarkets.com and ProfitingWithForex.com. His articles are regularly featured on online investing publications across the web.

Filed Under: Recent, Trading Lessons

Buy The Fear, Sell The Greed

Buy The Fear, Sell The Greed

Swing Trading College

New Book From Larry Connors and Chris Cain, CMT – "The Alpha Formula; High Powered Strategies to Beat The Market With Less Risk"

We’re excited to announce the release of a new investment book written by Larry Connors and Chris Cain, CMT. The book, “The Alpha Formula; High Powered Strategies to Beat The Market With Less Risk “ combines… Hedge fund legend Ray Dalio’s brilliant insight into combining uncorrelated strategies… With new, minimally correlated, quantified, systematic strategies to trade… [Read More]

Buy The Alpha Formula Now

Connors Research Traders Journal (Volume 57): 7 Real-World Reasons Why Short Strategies Should Be Included In Your Portfolio

In our new book, The Alpha Formula – High Powered Strategies to Beat the Market with Less Risk, we show the benefits of including short-strategies in your portfolio. As a reminder, building portfolios should be based on First Principles – otherwise known as truths. These truths are: Markets Go Up Market Go Down Markets Go… [Read More]

Company Info

The Connors Group, Inc.
185 Hudson St., Suite 2500
Jersey City, NJ 07311
www.cg3.com

About Us

About
Careers
Contact Us
Link To Us

Company Resources

Help
Privacy Policy
Return Policy
Terms & Conditions

Properties

TradingMarkets
Connors Research

Connect with TradingMarkets

Contact

info@cg3.com
973-494-7311 ext. 628

Free Book

Short Term Trading Strategies That Work

© Copyright 2020 The Connors Group, Inc.

Copyright © 2023 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in